Affirmative Repositioning (AR) MP Fredrick Shitana raised concerns about the possibility of the law being applied selectively, particularly against individuals or businesspeople based on their political affiliations or perceived opposition to those in power.

Shitana was contributing to the Tax Amendment Bill debate.

Shitana referred to previous parliamentary discussions on the Anti-Corruption Commission Bill, during which concerns were raised about the potential use of legislation against individuals perceived to be opposing the political establishment.

He further drew attention to a provision in the bill, which states that the President of the Tax Court may determine which judgements or decisions should be published for general information.

"That's why we are telling the minister here that we are not opposing; we are with hate, but we are just wondering. Is it going to really save all people, or is it going to be used against some individuals? Because we know when it comes to political times, there are certain business people who are threatened by law. If your tax is not in order, don't even say anything. If you are not complying with that, we launch a court against you. So that is the predicament we are dealing with."

Some MPs said Parliament should not have allowed the situation to persist for as long as it did, following a High Court ruling that declared provisions establishing the former Tax Appeal Court unconstitutional, effective 27 March 2021.

IPC MP Alosius Kangulu argued, "Taxpayers who disagree with the assessment had no way to have their dispute. That is not the technical inconvenience of our people, Speaker. It is a five-year denial of access to justice for the taxpayers, affecting ordinary taxpayers and quite a number of business people in their lives. At a time when this country can least afford uncertainty in its revenue administration, one could want to ask the Honourable Minister, "Why did it take five years to bring the limit to this House?"

AR MP Tuhafeni Kalola stated, "I support three things in this Bill. First one, I support the tax code as a division of the High Court. This gives it its independence. And it gives it teeth. A taxpayer and number will now stand before a real judge, not before a committee appointed by the minister. Secondly, I support the fact that a decision of the tax court is not final."

"We have an open justice principle, and all court cases are open for public scrutiny. However, the bill suggests that the sitting of the next court not be made public. "The same court will be using public money funded by the same taxpayer, so why not make it public?" questioned Swapo Party MP Marlyne Mbakera. 

NUDO MP Vetaruhe Kandorozu emphasised, "By establishing the new text court, a specialised division of the High Court presided over by a judge designated by the judge president, we restore the doctrine of the separation of power. We affirm the constitutional right of every Namibian to a fair, impartial and public hearing before an independent tribunal."

-

Category

Author
Joleni Shihapela