The natural diamond industry is facing growing competition from laboratory-grown stones, raising questions about what truly gives a diamond its value - rarity, origin or the story behind it.
For Namibia, the debate is becoming increasingly important as the industry seeks to protect its global market position.
Namdeb has acknowledged that synthetic diamonds are here to stay but maintains that natural stones occupy a distinct market, particularly among consumers seeking rarity and stones associated with significant life occasions.
This distinction is also central to De Beers' strategy.
Speaking at the unveiling of Namibia's 176-carat Owishi diamond in Washington, De Beers Chief Commercial Officer Mahiar Borhanjoo said synthetic diamonds have a role in technology and innovation, but natural diamonds carry a unique story linked to their origin and the communities where they are discovered.
De Beers is using its Tracr blockchain technology to trace diamonds from their rough origin to consumers, while its Origin De Beers initiative highlights their source and contribution to producing countries.
Owishi brings that story to life.
Recovered at Namdeb's Southern Coastal Mine in Oranjemund, the diamond is expected to return to Namibia for polishing by local artisans.
President Netumbo Nandi-Ndaitwah says the discovery comes at a time of changing consumer preferences, growing competition from laboratory-grown diamonds and volatility in international markets.
Dr Nandi-Ndaitwah is calling for greater local beneficiation through diamond cutting, polishing and jewellery manufacturing to retain more value within Namibia.
"This is a serious problem. As for Russia, what is the biggest impact of synthetic diamonds on natural diamonds? What is the impact?"
Botswana President Duma Boko has also defended the value of natural diamonds, highlighting their contribution to infrastructure, public services and livelihoods across producing countries.
Angolan President João Lourenço has called for African diamond-producing countries to strengthen cooperation and develop common mechanisms to protect the natural diamond industry from synthetic competition.
The debate goes beyond consumer preference. It concerns an industry that supports employment, generates export earnings and finances development across producing countries.
For Namibia, Owishi represents more than a rare 176-carat discovery. It highlights the challenge of turning rarity, origin and local beneficiation into lasting value in an increasingly competitive global diamond market.